*These events transpired some time ago and threw quite the wrench into my life for a short time so I wrote about them. You (the readers) are the first to know my side of the story in all honesty. My friend's name has been changed in this story to protect his identity but every other aspect is 100% true as it happened. We pick up in the midst of a fat girl's birthday party, which I have been talked into attending by my close friend and roommate, Shawn.*
Something about the way she's wiping my face with the washcloth is very inviting. The buttercream icing in my left eye isn't burning quite as bad as it was a few moments ago and the rhythmic movement of her fingers across my cheekbones is very calming. "There," she says, "all better." It's a line most young boys have heard from their mothers and I react with a smile, just like I used to for Mom.
I splash my face with water one final time to remove the last of the cupcake remnants. Moments before, I had been the victim of a cupcake-attack from the birthday girl, whose best friend was now standing before me in a closed-and-locked bathroom, half-drunkenly helping me recover.
I've had many interactions with my current female cohort - my roommate/very close friend Shawn has been very much infatuated with her for a month or so now and she has been frequenting my house during their time together. Her name is Ashley and frankly, I can't blame Shawn for his enthusiasm about her - she is quite pretty. Her curly brown hair bobs perfectly on her shoulders as I notice that she is maintaining her soft gaze - attempting to catch my eyes and hold them. I briefly elude, but then give up and instead lock souls with her - pupil to pupil to pupil to pupil. She starts speaking. I am lost in the wine and her gorgeous, fireburst retinas but manage to start comprehending as she says "... just some of the things I've heard you say lately are so... poignant."
...Honestly, I feel like that was a misuse of the word "poignant", a slight detail that ever-so-slightly annoys me.
Ashley and I have enjoyed several lengthy conversations about various topics over the past few weeks, but mostly just when she came over and grabbed a seat next to me at the arts/crafts/mischief table and started asking questions. I have considered her attractive from our first interaction, but I heavily compartmentalize when introduced to one of my friend's love-interests. In my own mind I have put up walls and blown up her flaws to remove any temptation to pursue her myself. I am known for disregarding the feelings of men with whom I am not friends, but I very much subscribe to the "Bros before hos" mantra and would never betray a friend over a woman... At this moment, however, with her breath on my face, ethanol in my blood and her hips grazing mine, I find myself oblivious to all previous thoughts of fighting Ashley's advances.
She is still speaking, but my mind is drifting to Shawn. He is sitting in an armchair in the other room, aimlessly flicking around on his phone and generally avoiding most of the other partygoers. I caught a glimpse of him in the recliner just moments before I was nearly decapitated via cupcake. He knows that I am in this bathroom with his girl and that she closed the door behind us - this far from an ideal state of affairs.
The "bro" in my head interjects for the first time all night and says "Dude, what are you thinking?! This is your friend's girl!" Before I can break her gaze and dart for the door, a different voice speaks up - one that reminds me of conversations between Shawn and I in which he admitted that he and Ashley were far from "together" in the sense that a modern couple identifies themselves. She is a twenty-year-old nursing student with a strong mind and a wild side, while he is a late-twenties father with an artistic side... they had different relationship goals, to say the least. With Ashley in search of fun and Shawn in search of love, the "relationship" has been doomed from day one, and frankly, part of me is starting to wonder if maybe Shawn isn't just reading more into the situation than he should be. He had, after all, been introduced to Ashley by a mutual friend, just hoping that they could find common ground. As best I can tell, they had found common ground over movies, and not a whole lot else.
Meanwhile, outside my own head, Ashley is still talking. I decide to tune back in at "you and I just seem to connect, on a different level, you know?"
Of course I know. She is one of the smartest girls I've met in a while and we had certainly taken notice of each other's mental prowess, but I choose to downplay her observation in favor of trying to end this situation and get us both back into the living room. If I can reunite with Shawn, I can make it hard for her to advance and try to convince him to leave. This was surely just the alcohol driving Ashley's words and there was no way that she found me preferable to him, right?... well... actually...... it makes sense. Fuck.
Without a word, I spin to face the mirror. "Looks like I'm cleaned up" I say quickly, reaching blindly for the door handle. She doesn't respond so I turn to face her again. Her head is tilted to one side, her eyes still burning bright as she subtley raises her eyebrows and smirks. If I had to translate the look she is giving me into words, they would read: "Don't kid yourself."
She's right again. Who am I kidding? Who is Shawn to stand between me and the prize that now stands before me? He had his chance and clearly Ashley has made her decision. Without another word she steps towards me. She presses her hips into mine as I lean back against the sink. Her eyes are locked with mine and our faces are almost touching. I can't back away any farther. This is happening.
Her tongue is in my mouth, probing around gently in search of mine. I hesitate, but finally commit. My eyes close, lips part submissively. I can't help but realize that I've never had a girl be so forward with me - normally I'm the aggressor and that's a role I've always embraced - this is unfamiliar territory.
At this point, my rational brain is shut down entirely. I have broken a cardinal rule amongst friends - though it wasn't my idea - and I should be feeling terrible about myself right now. Somewhere inside me, a tiny voice is screaming in fury at the side of me that allowed this to occur. Subconciously, I reach my arms out and grab Ashley's pelvis and then slide my right hand slowly up one side of her torso. Her body is firm and warm as she steps into my embrace, letting her hands do some wandering of their own. Four fingers slide between my belt and my pants, pulling me still closer. A hand runs it's way up my thigh. Ashley leans back and breaks our kiss, flashes me a smile for a moment before glancing towards my zipper. With another quick smile she starts to descend to her knees. Uh oh. The point of no return.
I want so badly to stop her, but I am quite simply too engrossed at this point to care that one of my closest friends is roughly 50 feet away, expecting Ashley and I to emerge momentarily from the bathroom to rejoin the party. On her knees now, Ashley reaches for my zipper when we are both startled.
*KNOCK KNOCK*
"HURRY UP IN THERE, JOSH IS SICK!"
It's the birthday girl, drunk herself, and clearly demanding we vacate the bathroom. Ashley glances up at me for instructions and I sieze the opportunity to regain control. "Stand up" I say, and she complies quickly.
"This cannot happen," I force out. "Shawn really likes you and I can't do this to him."
Her reaction surprises me. Up until this point, I have known Ashley to be a calm and collected adult. In this moment, she reveals her immaturity.
"Fuck that!" She outbursts. "He has a kid, I don't want deal with that shit."
"What do you mean?" I respond, "I love his son."
"Yeah, yeah, he's great but I don't want that. I want someone young and hot with no baggage."
I really can't blame her for such a desire, but I am disappointed that she has been stringing Shawn along if she has no intention of being with him. I start to formulate a response when we are interrupted again.
*KNOCK KNOCK* <
"Hey is Ashley in there?"
It was Shawn this time.
Fuck. Fuck. Fuck.
How am I going to explain that we have just been in here for close to five minutes for the sole purpose of wiping a little icing off my face? In an effort to quell suspicion, I reach again for the door handle, and with a quick "Get it together!" glance at Ashley, I threw the door open. There stands Shawn with his phone in hand, acting disinterested.
"Oh," he mutters, "what, were you two peeing together?"
He is clearly annoyed at the least, possibly more like "furious" - it's difficult to tell.
"Nah, she was just helping me get the icing out of my eye." I lie.
He makes eye contact with me for what feels like an eternity. Whether he realizes it or not, he is testing me. If my face cracks or wavers in any way, his subconsious lie detectors will light up like a Christmas tree. I call upon my years of experience playing tournament poker for assistance and my face remains stoic. He looks away after a few seconds, a concession that he either believes me or is willing to try to. I waste no time and walk right out of the bathroom and attempt to assimilate back into the party. Shawn stays behind at the bathroom door and starts speaking to Ashley. I have moved out of earshot at this point so I strike up a convesation with a slutty-looking blonde that I was pretend-flirting with an hour before. I have no interest in the blonde (Nicole? Natalie?), but it is my hope that Shawn will see me talking to her and assume that in my drunkeness I am simply extremely flirty tonight with all the females, not just "his" girl.
I feign interest and even exchange numbers with Nicole/Natalie before deciding to do something I hadn't done in a while - I need to take a walk. Walking aimlessly has always cleared my head and given me a chance to think things through alone before deciding on a course of action. If I can get a good walk in, I'll know exactly how to handle this juxtaposition.
I politely roll-off of my conversation with "Natacole" and walk out the front door into the night. It's a cool evening, a rarity for this time of year in Florida, and the wind whips at my clothing as I walk briskly down the sidewalk. Glancing upward, I start to pick out constellations and planets. Nerdy as it sounds, in times of stress I like to look at the night sky to remind me how small my problems really are in the grand scheme of things. Jupiter and Mars are particularly bright tonight, and I greet them aloud by name. It isn't long before I come across one of the many green electrical boxes that house the transformers that distribute electricity across this neighborhood. The transformer inside the box radiates heat and though I'm not feeling particularly cold, I sit on top of the box to enjoy it's warmth.
From my new perch, I withdraw my smartphone from my pocket. Sliding my finger across the screen to unlock it, I see that I've missed a call from my sister and that Natacole has already texted me. I quickly compose a text to Shawn: "Hey, ready to leave when you are." I want to say something about Ashley but I decide to tell him in person on the way home. Now that she is no longer in front of me, it's very easy to see that I need to inform Shawn of the things Ashley has said and the moves she has made. It will ruin my chances with Ashley (which is unfortunate because she is lucrative) but will preserve, if not strengthen my relationship with Shawn.
My phone informs me that my message has been sent and so I lean back for the moment and shoot another glance towards the Milky Way. Suddenly I hear acorns breaking and leaves crunching behind me. Footsteps.
I turn around quickly expecting a stranger. Unfortunately, it's Ashley.
"There you are," she says triumphantly, before quickly sitting down next to me on the electrical box. "I've been looking for you."
"Listen," I start, "this is a bad situation. We've both been drinking, Shawn is suspicious, I understand where you're coming from but you need to tell him that you aren't interested in a relationship with him." It felt good to be assertive.
Again, her retort caught me off guard. "Um, I've been nothing but upfront with him from the start. It's purely physical between us and at this point, I'm just glad that he introduced me to you."
Well... I wasn't expecting that. Again, my mind begins to churn. What if she was being truthful and Shawn had, in fact, been knowingly spinning his wheels this whole time? If she had told him not to read too much into their liasons, could she really be blamed if he had grown attached? This is not a decision that I want to make while drunk but I don't have much of a choice. Ashley is clearly a fellow master, and somehow, without warning, we are now making out again. She grabs my face with both hands and pulls it closer to hers. It feels like a very genuine display of affection.
This is bad. Here I am, under the stars with a girl that I can actually tolerate for once but the situation is horrendous. Any other time/place/situation and I'd be all about this but as the wine is metabolizing, I'm feeling worse and worse about what's already happened. Let alone the hand that is grabbing and rubbing at the back of my head as I'm lost in thought and the tongue that's grazing my tongue, "stopping the words from coming out" as Bright Eyes might put it.
Again, I suddenly hear acorns and leaves falling victim to shoes behind me. I instinctively break the kiss and turn swiftly. It's Shawn. Of course.
"Hey" he says, roughly 20 feet away and closing. His tone is calm and friendly... is it possible he didn't realize we were kissing?
"Hey" I respond.
"Are you ready to go?" He asks.
"Yeah, you?"
"Yeah, let's go."
"Okay."
I stand up and Ashley follows suit. I say nothing and fail to even acknowledge her as I step towards Shawn and we begin walking to his car in unison. I want so badly to say something - something to defer from the obvious akwardness of this situation. Something to let him know that I came here tonight with no ill intentions. Something to make myself seem less sinister. I can't think of anything, unfortunately.
We arrive at his car. I open the passenger door and start to sit down. "Okay, bye." Says Ashley, who has followed me to my door instead of following Shawn to his.
"Bye," I say, closing the door without so much as a glance her way. I am somewhat angry that she has put me in this situation.
She walks around the car. Hugs Shawn. Tells him goodbye. He goes for a kiss and gets rejected. I can't hear what they are saying. I don't want to.
Eventually Shawn sits down in the driver seat and turns on the car. He plugs his iPhone into his auxillary cable and puts on a Pandora station. We begin to roll forward. Underoath begins to play through his speakers.
I finally speak up. "So, I have to tell..." He cuts me off. "I know."
There is only music for several seconds.
"I'm sorry," I say.
Shawn says nothing, looks over at me, and turns up the music. As we both start to sing, he rolls the windows down. I am quite sure that we will have plenty to talk about tomorrow and there will likely be anger and pain. For the moment, however, we are two friends in a car listening to music and heading back to our house... and no matter what may happen, no one can take this away from us.